Published: Monday, 26th October, 2009 2:30pm
Brendan Rodgers - sack him or back him
Comments (46) | 
Print | 
Email
Should he stay or should he go?
Has the time come for Brendan Rodgers to be sacked, or should the underfire Royals boss be given more to time to turn things around at the Madejski Stadium?
Does Sir John Madejski need to act now to prevent the Royals slipping into League One and axe Rodgers, or should the chairman back his manager to get things right after a difficult summer of transition.
Let us know what you think and cast your vote in our Chronicle poll.
Del.icio.us
Digg
Facebook
Reddit
Stumbleupon
Jose's mate
(Unregistered User)
Oct 21 09 12:39
Our Ref: 5785
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Paying all that compensation to Watford, surely we have to give him time?! Perhaps Tommy Smith is his "kind of player," so it's a shame Reading tried to be underhand and not pay the asking price.
The guy is so arrogant, and his interviews are simply astounding in their content.
He's simply not good enough. How Watford must be laughing.
Report this comment
chris
(Unregistered User)
Oct 21 09 12:49
Our Ref: 5786
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Its got to be the boot! He is a joke.
This has been a matter of time after his shoking transfer moves and relentless arrogant interviews.
Beg Sir Coppell to save us.
Report this comment
Phil Nixon
(Unregistered User)
Oct 21 09 12:50
Our Ref: 5787
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
This season was all about rebuilding, so success is something we can defer to some extent, but we must not risk relegation. If, after the game on Monday, we look like staying in the relegation zone, then he has to go.
There's a Facebook group wanting Parkinson to replace him, with Coppell replacing Hammond. Maybe not such a daft idea?
Report this comment
roo
(Unregistered User)
Oct 21 09 13:31
Our Ref: 5792
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
thats not a bad one, sc upstairs and parky - but why do you think parky would come as i wouldn't if i was in his shoes
Report this comment
mobi jacanuff
(Unregistered User)
Oct 21 09 13:38
Our Ref: 5793
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Brendan will turn it round he did at watford!Brendan is special human being and he knows Jose Mourinho as he keeps telling us
Report this comment
Dave Aust
(Unregistered User)
Oct 21 09 13:39
Our Ref: 5794
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
We new it was going to be bad and it would take time to blend the players into a team. However, Rogers simply seems to have no idea who he wants to play chopping and changing team selection week in week out. What chance have the players, who arn't that bad, actually got of building up any sort of understanding with this sort of approach. Time to go me thinks...
Report this comment
strap
(Unregistered User)
Oct 21 09 14:20
Our Ref: 5795
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
"Brendan will turn it round he did at watford!Brendan is special human being and he knows Jose Mourinho as he keeps telling us"
Nonsense - things turned at Watford when Malky MacKay was added to the coacghing staff.
This arrogant no-mark needs to clear off sharp*sh. Phoning SSC to thank him for bequeathing a talented set of players?!?! Just who the hell does he think he is?
No doubt SSC listened politely and thanked him for his call as he's that kind of bloke. If that had been me I'd told him where to go!!
Report this comment
MacRoyal
(Unregistered User)
Oct 21 09 14:45
Our Ref: 5797
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
I was happy to back BR when he joined and understand that the club has changed. However, League 1 football is not an option. The players are good enough to maintain mid-table at least and they need to be told that. Lose to Leicester and it should be over. Can't understand how SJM would want to risk it anymore, it's his money that's going down the drain?! We urgently need a goalscorer to bring some confidence into the team. Players don't know if they're part of his plans or not. Now BR says that he needs 'his' kind of players, that won't help team morale!
Report this comment
MacRoyal
(Unregistered User)
Oct 21 09 14:46
Our Ref: 5798
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
I was happy to back BR when he joined and understand that the club has changed. However, League 1 football is not an option. The players are good enough to maintain mid-table at least and they need to be told that. Lose to Leicester and it should be over. Can't understand how SJM would want to risk it anymore, it's his money that's going down the drain?! We urgently need a goalscorer to bring some confidence into the team. Players don't know if they're part of his plans or not. Now BR says that he needs 'his' kind of players, that won't help team morale!
Report this comment
Brenda Rodgers
(Unregistered User)
Oct 21 09 15:19
Our Ref: 5799
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Please stop picking on my Brendan, don't you know how special he is?
I think it's the fans should all be sacked for doubting the messiah.
Report this comment
de parr
(Unregistered User)
Oct 21 09 17:34
Our Ref: 5800
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
our premership dream has come and gone,a football club suicide by Hammond, Madeaski and the board,and Rodgers who hasnt a clue the fall guy, we are now nearer the conference than the premier after just two years, the football world looks on and laughs
Report this comment
You 'orns
(Unregistered User)
Oct 21 09 20:29
Our Ref: 5806
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Please, please, please don't sack him yet.
After the sheer comedy of the Tommy Smith saga, then you actually paid us for McAnuff, this is the icing on the cake to see the messiah fail. I'm sure everything he learnt under Jose will see him through.
You should be made to wait until he realises why everyone hates him. That may take a while yet though if the comments he made after we played you are anything to go by. He still thinks it's because he left us !
Lol ! It's all about your (lack of) integrity Brenda.
Give him to Christmas and then Madjeski can sack him. That should give someone enough time to save you as I have no beef with Reading FC.
Don't expect him to walk away though. Can you see someone that arrogant resigning ? Especially when he doesn't have "his kind of player". Not even the ones he signed ?
Report this comment
Franklin D Roosevelt
(Unregistered User)
Oct 22 09 06:01
Our Ref: 5810
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Things would have been sooo much better if only tommy smith had signed instead of choosing the premiership!!!!!
Feel sorry for reading i really do. He did turn things round at watford... but mackay had already started that in his 5 games as caretaker.
We were annoyed at him, now we're laughing.
But like 'you 'orns' i have no beef with reading and really do hope you get it sorted... but with a diff manager.
Report this comment
Hornet Cornet
(Unregistered User)
Oct 22 09 08:38
Our Ref: 5812
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Hornet Cornet here,
I have to say that Judas has got everything coming to him. He has no morals, no scruples and a hugely self-inflated opinion of himself and his ethics. Reading need to get rid of this waster pronto otherwise you'll have the pleasure of playing teams like Southend next season, not good eh.
I could go on another rant about Judas Rodgers bu****hink I'll go and sit smugly in front of the Championship table instead, gazing happiluy at the impending doom that will descend upon Judas when he gets sacked.
Cornetto
Report this comment
Michael Anthony
(Unregistered User)
Oct 22 09 09:59
Our Ref: 5814
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Dear reading Football fans:
When Brendan Rodgers came to Reading his ideas could have been seen as refreshing. For example he stated he wanted to play European football. However after even \'poor\' games he appears to always be positive about the future direction, even after defeat after defeat. I do wonder if he has been watching the same game as me on occasions. I am aware that Scott Davies wants to stay at Wycombe. I wonder why?
I big question is how long does Sir John give Brendan to change things around? Sir John is a business man and I therefore wonder when is he going to get involved with \'sorting out\' this mess. I am not convienced that unless there are changes (certainly before the tranferee window)Reading will be in the first division next year.
I already think Reading will be bottom on the table by the end of November. The crowds are staying away as the results continue to be poor. I travel from Dorset each game and as a season ticket holder do wonder why I paid for 2 tickets this year. I along with many others will not renew this commitment next season as if I believe, Reading will be relegated and why travel 162 miles (round trip) to watch what can only de discribed as awful clueless football.
I don\'t normally write on messaging blogs but can the management at Reading FC please make some positive moves before the situation is too late.
Report this comment
Paul
(Unregistered User)
Oct 22 09 11:59
Our Ref: 5819
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
I think he has until the end on November to turn it around but can't see anything happening until we play 4-4-2.
Report this comment
Cenobite
(Unregistered User)
Oct 22 09 13:56
Our Ref: 5822
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Don't sack him. Its far more fun watching the 2 faced scrote being slowly broken.
Did he mention that he used to be at Chelsea and knows Jose?!?!?!
Report this comment
frank
(Unregistered User)
Oct 22 09 17:15
Our Ref: 5830
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Please dont sack him we so want to show him what we really think when he returns to the vic on the last game of the season, if he thought the 3500 away fans gave him a hard time recently then you have not seen anything yet.\\r\\n\\r\\nnice fans nice town but what a w..... of a manager and assistant as lets not forget the ass kissing Austin in all of this!\\r\\n\\r\\nOh and Jose sends his regards, you do know he is good mates with John and Frank as well dont you, and do you know he went to dinner with Cheryl and Ash the other night great left back great left back oh and dont question his integrity i love it at watford and please dont question me about leaving again im here to stay.\\r\\n\\r\\ndo i need to say more reading fans.... get him out before your relegated, he thinks he done a good job at watford it was our current manager that changed the style we were playing and then we got a few results before he walked out, dont be fooled he is a fake!
Report this comment
frank
(Unregistered User)
Oct 22 09 17:16
Our Ref: 5831
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
GET A REALITY CHECK READING FANS I KNOW JOSE YOU KNOW!
Report this comment
Hornet Cornet
(Unregistered User)
Oct 22 09 20:43
Our Ref: 5838
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Dear Royals,
I'm guessing that you're starting to realise what us Hornets think of Judas? If he's still in charge at the end of the season then he's going to get a right rollocking off of us lot. The treatment he received at the Madjeski was a little sampler of the abuse he'll get at out place.
Happy Royalling
Report this comment
frank
(Unregistered User)
Oct 22 09 20:52
Our Ref: 5840
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
GET A REALITY CHECK READING FANS I KNOW JOSE YOU KNOW!
Report this comment
The Man With The Child In His Eyes
(Unregistered User)
Oct 22 09 21:02
Our Ref: 5841
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Like some people on this thread, I realise Reading have to rebuild and because of that I was willing to give to Rodgers a chance when he came here.
However, he seems intent on paying homage to Terry Bullivant's reign of misery.
And just like TB, what exactly IS the point in letting decent players go if you're not willing to get some decent replacements?
If the players don't know if they're part of his plans or not then that's a classic sign of bad management!
Maybe Sir John should stop holding a candle to Cilla and take a good look at the mess Reading are in!
Report this comment
The Man With The Child In His Eyes
(Unregistered User)
Oct 22 09 21:51
Our Ref: 5843
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Like some people on this thread, I realise Reading have to rebuild and because of that I was willing to give to Rodgers a chance when he came here.
However, he seems intent on paying homage to Terry Bullivant's reign of misery.
And just like TB, what exactly IS the point in letting decent players go if you're not willing to get some decent replacements?
If the players don't know if they're part of his plans or not then that's a classic sign of bad management!
Maybe Sir John should stop holding a candle to Cilla and take a good look at the mess Reading are in!
Report this comment
The Man With The Child In His Eyes
(Unregistered User)
Oct 22 09 22:52
Our Ref: 5846
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Like some people on this thread, I realise Reading have to rebuild and because of that I was willing to give to Rodgers a chance when he came here.
However, he seems intent on paying homage to Terry Bullivant's reign of misery.
And just like TB, what exactly IS the point in letting decent players go if you're not willing to get some decent replacements?
If the players don't know if they're part of his plans or not then that's a classic sign of bad management!
Maybe Sir John should stop holding a candle to Cilla and take a good look at the mess Reading are in!
Report this comment
mactheknife
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 02:39
Our Ref: 5881
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Brendon Rodgers...... it's all been said but, i can't help but beg the Board to consider any alternative! Dare I mention Mark McGee or Allan Pardew? I hear Mad Dog may be out of favour at Cheltenham???
Report this comment
WatfordSup
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 11:35
Our Ref: 5887
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Watford supporter here.
All of our Watford Supporter gang likes what kind of prediciment that JUDAS is in and laughs. He said that he would give us survial he did that, he said that he he was here for the long haul he went to you.
He said to ur club that he will get you promoted, he will get you relegated at this moment. Thanks for buying our wasters as we are doing better without them.
For us Malky Mackay is 100 times better than rodgers. If you sack him, to come to us and poach him.
Have fun in Oldham and Carlisle and yeovil next season.
have fun at
Report this comment
WatfordSup
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 11:47
Our Ref: 5888
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Watford supporter here.
All of our Watford Supporter gang likes what kind of prediciment that JUDAS is in and laughs. He said that he would give us survial he did that, he said that he he was here for the long haul he went to you.
He said to ur club that he will get you promoted, he will get you relegated at this moment. Thanks for buying our wasters as we are doing better without them.
For us Malky Mackay is 100 times better than rodgers. If you sack him, to come to us and poach him.
Have fun in Oldham and Carlisle and yeovil next season.
have fun at
Report this comment
WatfordSup
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 11:47
Our Ref: 5889
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Watford supporter here.
All of our Watford Supporter gang likes what kind of prediciment that JUDAS is in and laughs. He said that he would give us survial he did that, he said that he he was here for the long haul he went to you.
He said to ur club that he will get you promoted, he will get you relegated at this moment. Thanks for buying our wasters as we are doing better without them.
For us Malky Mackay is 100 times better than rodgers. If you sack him, to come to us and poach him.
Have fun in Oldham and Carlisle and yeovil next season.
have fun at
Report this comment
hornet cornet
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 12:29
Our Ref: 5892
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Ha ha ha, this is becoming a Watford board. This is toooo funny !!
HC
Report this comment
imuz
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 12:47
Our Ref: 5893
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Hahahahaha. For those of you that think us Watford fans must be having a good old chuckle at your expense....just to confirm for you all...WE ARE!!! HAHAHA
Oh Brenda what have you done?!?!
Report this comment
imuz
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 13:08
Our Ref: 5898
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Just dont go questioning his integrity he wont be happy!!
Report this comment
hornet cornet
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 13:18
Our Ref: 5900
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
hello imuz, nice to see you, to see you nice. Seen who's in the relegation zone of the championship? I wonder who it could be.....
HC
Report this comment
hornet cornet
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 13:32
Our Ref: 5902
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
hello imuz, nice to see you, to see you nice. Seen who's in the relegation zone of the championship? I wonder who it could be.....
HC
Report this comment
hornet cornet
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 13:36
Our Ref: 5903
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
hello imuz, nice to see you, to see you nice. Seen who's in the relegation zone of the championship? I wonder who it could be.....
HC
Report this comment
hornet cornet
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 13:42
Our Ref: 5904
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
hello imuz, nice to see you, to see you nice. Seen who's in the relegation zone of the championship? I wonder who it could be.....
HC
Report this comment
imuz
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 15:07
Our Ref: 5907
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
hehe. Sack him and give the job to Nigel Gibbs (he knows Graham Taylor don\'t you know) but not until we relegate you on the last day of the season..
Report this comment
hornet cornet
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 16:50
Our Ref: 5910
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
How sweet that would be. Beating the unRoyals to send them down on the last day of the season whilst also assuring us of the Championshipt*tle.
Happy days are just around the corner Hornets!
Report this comment
Ollis chateau South of Watford
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 19:33
Our Ref: 5913
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Nothing against Reading F C, ha ha (other than the fact you quite happily took a point with the goal that wasn't) then you quite happily took Brendan Rodgers,then you quite happily would have shafted us by taking Tommy Smith for peanuts..........well look whose been shafted now!!!!!!! Brenda Integrity was a mistake by us, Malky should have got the job first time round,so i guess all in all its a case of"ALL's WELL THAT ENDS WELL"
Report this comment
Ollis chateau South of Watford
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 19:44
Our Ref: 5915
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
There is only one and always will be one
"SPECIAL ONE"
-GT-GT-GT-GT-GT-GT-GT-GT-GT-GT-GT-GT-GT-GT-GT-GT-
Report this comment
priesty
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 20:45
Our Ref: 5916
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
i think everyone should get behind brendan and the royals no one should blame brendan he has been given peanuts by john madjeski so what does he exspect its not his fault if reading cant score everyone goes on about how well coppell did which he did but when the going got tough he left we might be in the relegation zone now but a few wins under are belt and we will be mid-table again, brendan puts out a good team every week which arent performing how can you blame him for that? back brendan and the boys, BRENDAN RODGERS BARMY ARMY !
Report this comment
Hornet Cornet
(Unregistered User)
Oct 27 09 21:52
Our Ref: 5920
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Dear Priesty,
How much did Judas waste on McNotEnuff? The chances that Mobi JacEnuff wasted go to show that he is sub-standard as a striker / front man. We saw this at Watford yet Brenda still managed to furnish our pockets with silly money for a rubbish player.
As for Brenda putting out a good team each week, he never sticks with the same team nor formation so how can he be putting the same team out every week?
Dont get me wrong, the more he loses, the happier us Hornets will be but, at the end of the day (and as Ollis Chateau said), we're happy and the unRoyals aren't.
Bon nuit mon pot.
Cornetto
Report this comment
Edward_DA_Royal
(Unregistered User)
Nov 19 09 11:31
Our Ref: 6415
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Hello Watfords Fans,
Yes we maybe in the bottom three atm, but we are playing well and I am sure the strike force will improve to get the hat full goals we deserve both home and away.
I'm happy atm with the re-building process and don't think we be relegated and we will be playing Watford next season.
But hats off to you guys, you are certainly pulling in the results, but it is a long hard season.
But I supose its your time in the sun, so enjoy your moment guys.
Regards
A Royal for ever!!!!!!!!! (even if we do get relegated to the lower leagues)
Report this comment
Edward_DA_Royal
(Unregistered User)
Nov 19 09 11:40
Our Ref: 6416
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Hello Watfords Fans,
Yes we maybe in the bottom three atm, but we are playing well and I am sure the strike force will improve to get the hat full goals we deserve both home and away.
I'm happy atm with the re-building process and don't think we be relegated and we will be playing Watford next season.
But hats off to you guys, you are certainly pulling in the results, but it is a long hard season.
But I supose its your time in the sun, so enjoy your moment guys.
Regards
A Royal for ever!!!!!!!!! (even if we do get relegated to the lower leagues)
Report this comment
Edward_DA_Royal
(Unregistered User)
Nov 19 09 14:13
Our Ref: 6421
Use the ref number if you need to report this comment
Hello Watfords Fans,
Yes we maybe in the bottom three atm, but we are playing well and I am sure the strike force will improve to get the hat full goals we deserve both home and away.
I'm happy atm with the re-building process and don't think we be relegated and we will be playing Watford next season.
But hats off to you guys, you are certainly pulling in the results, but it is a long hard season.
But I supose its your time in the sun, so enjoy your moment guys.
Regards
A Royal for ever!!!!!!!!! (even if we do get relegated to the lower leagues)
Report this comment
For your convenience, you can now register with our website (which will save you from having to retype your name each time you post a comment). If you would like to do this (or have already!) then please Log in or Register